It all started with the query, ‘Gay son or thot daughter?’ circulated online asking people to decide if they want their imaginary child to be promiscuous or gay. Fortunately, majority responded that they would love their child regardless of who they were, seeing through the problematic nature of the question. Despite this, the question still exists online. There must be a pushback when something so poisonous is allowed to flourish so openly, and the Thought Daughter became that pushback.
The Thought Daughter philosophy aims to strike a compromise between contemporary feminism and more compassionate and gentler principles. It is frequently contested because second wave feminism portrayed women as being on par with men in every way, turning them into cogs in a capitalist machine rather than levelling the playing field to ensure that the ruthless and the compassionate received equal opportunities. Many people fear that giving up on equality in a capitalist system would mean giving up on everyone being equal. This is why second wave feminism triumphed in the face of misogyny.
As a psychologist, Mehezabin Dordi finds the rise of the Thought Daughter—a term born from social media but rooted in real psychological patterns—both timely and important. This archetype represents a young woman who is deeply introspective, intellectually inclined, emotionally attuned, and often quietly burdened by a sense of responsibility that far exceeds her years.
A prevalent aspect of the human experience is overthinking. Thought Daughter has become such a global phenomenon as the result of a lifetime of overthinking, which is a major part of growing up as a woman, particularly in India. Her ability to think and act smart is a survival strategy. Before she really comprehends the idea, a girl child is taught to shoulder the responsibility of accountability.
Unlike the traditionally assertive and outspoken eldest daughter, the Thought Daughter is more internalised in her distress. She overthinks, people-pleases, anticipates emotional needs around her, and often suppresses her own in order to maintain harmony. Ms Dordi shares that in her practice, she has seen how these daughters are praised for being mature, self-sufficient, or low maintenance, which often results in their emotional needs being overlooked or invalidated.
She needs to consider social graces, her family's dignity, upholding tradition, love, which frequently requires unwarranted compromise, and her personal safety. A woman learns early on that she needs to put in twice as much effort to accomplish a small portion of what men accomplish. She is taught that she needs to put a lot of effort into her studies, sometimes to delay marriage and live an independent life, and other times to make herself more ‘suitable’ for it. Her early academic pressure and hyperawareness set her on a course that eventually leads to a thorough philosophical analysis of who she is and where she fits in the world.
Over time, this can manifest as anxiety, burnout, perfectionism, or identity diffusion. What these daughters need most is for caregivers to recognise the invisible emotional labour they perform and to actively create space for their voices, vulnerabilities, and needs. It’s vital to validate their inner world, model healthy boundaries, and make it clear that their value isn’t tied to how well they manage others’ emotions or how much they achieve. Encourage rest without guilt, welcome emotional expression without rushing to solutions, and help them differentiate between being empathetic and being responsible for everyone else’s well-being.
When caregivers offer consistent emotional safety and space for authentic self-expression, the thought daughter’s sensitivity and depth can become powerful assets rather than sources of quiet suffering.
Image source: Substack, News xcp, Penguin libros